As the US recovers from the devastation brought about by the unexpected
Tornado, the religious and the secular factions will be out arguing the
usual causes behind it. As for the political section, there is silence;
this time there is no Al-Qaeda, no terrorists or the extreme far right
to blame. Such events do bring about our philosophical thoughts to the
surface; it gets us to think about the nature and the meaning of life
and the universe. An event beyond our control causing so much
devastation, killing indiscriminately, why does this happen? Some say it
is a random event, the work of Mother Nature, and others say it is God
sending down collective punishment. Depending on how you interpret the
event, it can either bring a person to conviction in the existence of a
Creator, or reaffirm his denial of a Creator, as is the current fad.
If it is the former, the trail of thought is on the basis of observing
the frailty and weakness of the human species. There must be something
more powerful that has ensured the survival of the human race; otherwise
we could have become extinct through major calamities in the past, and
there has been plenty starting from the ice age. As for those who
move towards the other direction, increasing their conviction in the
absence of a benevolent Creator argue: how can God permit such evil,
calamitous events kills saints and sinners indiscriminately; this is the
age-old question from the atheist corner. And calamitous events add
credence to the argument that there is no such thing as a loving God,
maybe a killer God, but is that not an oxymoron? In fact that makes the
case for Devil worshipping.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ffeeb/ffeeb1baf4cd3759bd5cccfaf3b04854e0c4b989" alt=""
However, who says calamities and hardship can be equated to evil, and
that God cannot inflict hardship on his creation? Isn’t that an
assumption? If we build on this premise then one can argue by inference
that hardship of any kind is evil on a smaller scale, hence the pain
experienced through child birth or the toil in earning a living is also
evil. This creates more questions than answers; clearly this is not a
consistent viewpoint.
According to Islamic theology evil is disobedience to God, it relates
entirely to the way we exercise our free will and is no relation to the
natural events around us. If we kill others without a just cause, then
we have taken a life without a divine permit and there is retribution
for this evil deed. But can the same logic be applied to God, who is the
Creator and the legal owner of life. Even in the realm of the human
sphere, if I build a house, it is my prerogative to burn it down as I am
its legal owner. What stops me from smashing my car in the garage?
Thus what law stops God from taking the life that he created in the
first place?